Abstract
In this paper we set out to examine thearguments for and against the claim thatEvidence-Based Medicine (EBM) will improve thequality of care. In particular, we examine thefollowing issues:
1. Are there hidden ethical assumptions in the methodology of EBM?2. Is there a tension between the duty of care and EBM?3. How can patient preferences be incorporated into quality guidelines and effectiveness studies?4. Is there a tension between the quality of a particular intervention and overall quality of care?5. Are certain branches of medicine and patient groups innately or prima facie disadvantaged by a shift to EBM?
In addition we consider a case study in theethics of EBM, on a clinical trial concerningthe collection of umbilical cord blood inutero and ex utero, during or afterlabour in childbirth.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allain, H. (2001) New Drug Therapies: How Far Can We Stretch Ethics? Country report on EBM in France. Paper presented at the Maastricht Evibase workshop, 2 February.
Ashcroft, R., Hope, T. and Parker, M. (2001) Ethical Issues and Evidence-Based Patient Choice. In A. Edwards and G. Elwyn (Eds.), Evidence-Based Patient Choice: Inevitable or Impossible? (pp. 53-65). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bellaby, P. (2001) Evidence and Risk: The Sociology of Health Care Grappling with Knowledge and Uncertainty. In A. Edwards and Glyn E. (Eds.), Evidence-Based Patient Choice: Inevitable or Impossible? (pp. 78–94). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Berg, M. (1995) Rationalizing Medical Work: Decision Support Techniques and Medical Practices. Maastricht: Rijksuniversiteit Limburg.
Berg, M. (1996) Problemen en Potenties van het Protocol, de Voorwaarden om Protocollen Positief in te Zetten. Medisch Contact 11, 366–370.
Blettner, M., Sauerbrei, W., Schlehofer, B., Scheucherenpflug, T. and Friedenreich, C. (1999) Traditional Reviews, Meta-Analyses and Pooled Analyses in Epidemiology. International Journal of Epidemiology 28, 1–9.
Chalmers, I. (1993) The Cochrane Collaboration: Preparing, Maintaining and Disseminating Systematic Reviews of the Effects of Health Care. Annals of the New York Academy of Science 703, 156–163.
Clough, P. (1979) The Validation of Meaning in Illness-Treatment Situations. In D. Hall and M. Stacey (Eds.), Beyond Separation. London: Routledge.
Cochrane, A. (1999) Effectiveness and Efficiency. London: RSM Press.
Cohen-Kettenis, P.T., Dekker, J.H., Groot, P.A. de, Raben, C.J.T. and Trijsburg, R.W. (2000) Naar Geïntegreerde Richtlijnen in de GGZ. De Visie van de Landelijke Stuurgroep Multidisciplinaire Richtlijnontwikkeling in de Geestelijke Gezondheidszorg. Maandblad Geestelijke Volksgezondheid 9, 782–789.
Dickenson, D. (1995) Is Efficiency Ethical? Resource Issues in Health Care. In B. Almond (Ed.), An Introduction to Applied Ethics (pp. 229-246). Oxford: Blackwell.
Dickenson, D. (1999) Can Medical Criteria Settle Priority-Setting Debates? The Need for Ethical Analysis. Health Care Analysis 7, 1–7.
Dickenson, D. (2001) Commentary on Biller-Andorno and Karageorgiou. Paper presented at the Maastricht Evibase workshop, 2 February.
Edwards, A. and Bastian, H. (2001) Risk Communication–Making Evidence Part of Patient Choices. In A. Edwards and G. Elwyn (Eds.), Evidence-Based Patient Choice: Inevitable or Impossible? (pp. 144-160). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fabris, F. and Scarafiotti, C. (2002) Are Particular Patients Disadvantaged by EBM? Paper presented at the Evibase Turin workshop, March.
FIGO (International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics) (1998) Ethical Guidelines Regarding the Procedure of Collection of Cord Blood. Cairo FIGO, http://www.figo.org.
Gezondheidsraad (The Netherlands) (2000) Van Implementeren naar Leren. Het Belang van Tweerichtingsverkeer Tussen Praktijk en Wetenschap in de Gezondheidszorg. Den Haag: Gezondheidsraad.
Gøtzsche, P. and Olsen, O. (2000) Is Screening for Breast Cancer with Mammography Justifiable? The Lancet 355, 129–134.
Gluckmann, E. (2001) Paper delivered at meeting of the European Science Research Group, Brussels, November.
Guyatt, G., Sackett, D., Sinclair, J., Hayward, R., Cook, D. and Cook, R. (1995) A New Method for Grading Health Care Recommendations. Journal of the American Medical Association 274(22), 1800–1804.
Harrison, S. (1998) The Politics of Evidence-Based Medicine in the United Kingdom. Policy and Politics 26(1), 15–31.
Hope, T. (1995) Editorial: Evidence-Based Medicine and Ethics. Journal of Medical Ethics 21(5),259–260.
Hope, T. (1996) Evidence-Based Patient Choice–A Report to the Anglia and Oxford Regional Health Authority into the Use of Evidence-Based Information for Enhancing Patient Choice. London: King's Fund Publications.
Irwin, A. (1995) Citizen Science. London: Routledge.
Kasenbrood, J.A. (1997) Evidence-Based Medicine en de Dagelijkse Psychiatrische Praktijk. Kwaliteit and Zorg 2, 50–60.
Lie, R. (2001a) Commentary at Evibase workshop, Maastricht, February.
Lie, R. (2001b) Country Report on Norway. Evibase workshop, Maastricht, February.
Morley, G.M. (1998) Cord Closure: Can Hasty Clamping Injure the Newborn? Obstetrics and Gynaecology Management, July.
Muir Grey, J.A. (1997) Evidence-Based Health Care: How to Make Health Policy and Management Decisions. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Orsi, L. and Bianchi, A. (1998) Cittadino Insoddisfatto, Sanità in Trasformazione: Una Possibile Lettura Bioetica del Problema. Bioetica, 15–26.
Pagliaro, L. (2001) Paper given at the London Evibase workshop, June.
Peltonen, T. (1981) Placental Tansfusion-Advantage and Disadvantage. European Journal of Pediatrics 137, 141–146.
Sackett, D.L., Rosenberg, W.M., Gray, J.A., Haynes, R.B. and Richardson, W.S. (1996) Evidence Based Medicine: What It Is and What It Isn't. BMJ 312(7023), 71–72.
Sepers, C. and ter Meulen, R. (2001) Health Care and EBM in the Netherlands. Paper presented at the Maastricht Evibase workshop, 2 February.
Ter Meulen, R.H.J and van den Burg, M. (1999) Evidence-Based Medicine en de Solidariteit Tussen Generaties. In J.J.M. Delden, C.M.P.M. van Hertogh and H.A.M. Manschot (Eds.), Morele Problemen in de Ouderenzorg (pp. 139-154).
Thomas, V. (2002) Patient-Controlled Analgesia and Sickle Cell Disease. In K.W.M. Fulford, D.L. Dickenson and T.H. Murray (Eds.), The Blackwell Reader in Healthcare Ethics and Human Values (pp. 252-257). Oxford: Blackwell.
Tromp, S. (2001) Seize the Day, Seize the Cord. Unpublished undergraduate medical dissertaion, University of Maastricht.
Towle, A. and Godolphin, W. (2001) Education and Training of Health Care Professionals. In A. Edwards and G. Elwyn (Eds.), Evidence-Based Patient Choice: Inevitable or Impossible? (pp. 245-269). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Viano, C. Il caso Di Bella e la Rivolta contro la Medicina Scientifica. Bioetica, 198–206.
Vineis, P. (2000) The Tension between Ethics and Evidence-Based Medicine. Turin: University of Turin and CPO-Piemonte.
Vlieland, T.V. (2002) EBM and Chronic Disease Management: Boundless Opportunities or an Endless Task? Paper presented at the Turin Evibase workshop, March.
Wallace, L. (1986) Informed Consent in Elective Surgery: The “Therapeutic” Value. Social Science and Medicine 22(1), 29–33.
Weinman, J. (1990) ProvidingWritten Information for Patients: Psychological Considerations. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 88, 303–305.
Wilcken, N., Ghersi, D., Brunswick, C., Clarke, M. and Ganz, P. (2000) More on Mammography. The Lancet 356, 1275–1276.
Zulueta, P de. (2000) The Ethics of Anonymised HIV Testing of Pregnant Women: A Reappraisal. Journal of Medical Ethics 26, 16–21.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dickenson, D., Vineis, P. Evidence-Based Medicine and Quality of Care. Health Care Analysis 10, 243–259 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1022995623172
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1022995623172