Abstract
The construct of emotional intelligence (EI) has gained increasing popularity over the last 10 years and now has a relatively large academic and popular associated literature. EI is beginning to be discussed within the medical education literature, where, however, it is treated uncritically. This reflections paper aims to stimulate thought about EI and poses the question: Are we trying to measure the unmeasurable? The paper begins with an outline of the relevance and meaningfulness of the topic of EI for doctors. It continues with an overview of the main models and measures of EI. We then critique the psychometric properties of EI measures and give an illustrative case study where we tested the psychometric properties of the ECI-U with medical students. After our critique, we present an alternative model of EI and outline possible future directions for educational research.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Association of American Medical Colleges. (1998). Learning objectives for medical student education. Medical school objectives project. USA: Association of American Medical Colleges. Retrieved February 21, 2004, from http://www.aamc.org/meded/msop/start.htm
R. Bar-On (1988) The Development of a Concept of Psychological Well-being. Unpublished doctoral dissertation Rhodes University South Africa
R. Bar-On (1997) Bar-On Emotional Quotient Inventory (EQI).Technical Manual Multi-Health Systems Toronto, Canada
Bleakley, A. (in press). Broadening conceptions of learning in medical education: The message from teamworking. Medical Education
D. Boud (1981) Developing Student Autonomy in Learning Kogan Page London
R. Boyatzis (1982) The Competent Manager: A Model for Effective Performance Wiley New York
R.E. Boyatzis D. Goleman (2001) Emotional Competence Inventory – University Version. Self-assessment Questionnaire, Profile and Interpretive Notes Hay Resources Direct London
R.E. Boyatzis D. Goleman K.S. Rhee (2000) Clustering competencies in emotional intelligence: Insights from the Emotional Competency Inventory (ECI) R. Bar-On J.D. Parker (Eds) The Handbook of Emotional Intelligence Jossey-Bass San Francisco 343–362
R.E. Boyatzis M. Burckle (1999) Psychometric Properties of the ECI Hay/McBer Group Boston
R.M. Carrothers S.W. Gregory T.J. Gallagher (2000) ArticleTitleMeasuring emotional intelligence of medical school applicants Academic Medicine 75 456–463
Channel 4. Superhuman (2004). UK: Channel 4. Retrieved April 17, 2004, from http://www,.channel4.com/science/microsites/S/superhuman/
J. Ciarrochi A. Chan P. Caputi R. Roberts (2001) Measuring emotional intelligence J. Ciarrochi J.P. Forgas J.D. Mayer (Eds) Emotional Intelligence in Everyday Life: A Scientific Inquiry Psychology Press Taylor & Francis Philadelphia 25–45
J.M. Conte (2005) ArticleTitleA review and critique of emotional intelligence measures Journal of Organizational Behaviour 26 433–440
A.R. Damasio (1994) Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason and The Human Brain HarperCollins New York
M. Davies L. Stankov R. Roberts (1998) ArticleTitleEmotional intelligence: In search of an elusive construct Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 75 989–1015
D. Dawda S.D. Hart (2000) ArticleTitleAssessing emotional intelligence: reliability and validity of the Bar-On Emotional Quotient Inventory (EQ-i) in university students Personality and Individual Differences 28 797–812 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0191-8869(99)00139-7
A.L. Day S.A. Carroll (2004) ArticleTitleUsing an ability-based measure of emotional intelligence to predict individual performance, group performance, and group citizenship behaviours Personality and Individual Differences 36 1443–1458 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0191-8869(03)00240-X
V.U. Druskat S.B. Wolff (2001a) ArticleTitleBuilding the emotional intelligence of groups Harvard Business Review 79 IssueID3 80–90
V.U. Druskat S.B. Wolff (2001b) Group emotional intelligence and its influence in group effectiveness C. Cherniss D. Goleman (Eds) The Emotionally Intelligent Workplace: How to Select for, Measure and Improve Emotional Intelligence in Individuals, Groups, and Organizations Jossey Bass San Francisco
C. Elam T.D. Stratton M.A. Andrykowski (2001) ArticleTitleMeasuring the emotional intelligence of medical school matriculants Academic Medicine 76 507–508
Y. Engestrom (1987) Learning by Expanding Orienta Konsultit Oy Helsinki
R.M. Epstein (2002) ArticleTitleDefining and assessing professional competence Journal of The American Medical Association 287 226–235 Occurrence Handle10.1001/jama.287.2.226
M.D. Feldman (2001) ArticleTitleBecoming an emotionally intelligent physician Western Journal of Medicine 175 98 Occurrence Handle10.1136/ewjm.175.2.98
S.W. Fraser T. Greenhalgh (2001) ArticleTitleCoping with complexity: Educating for capability British Medical Journal 323 799–802
General Medical Council (2003). Tomorrow’s Doctors: Recommendations on undergraduate medical education, 2nd edn. London: General Medical Council. Retrieved September 30, 2003, from http://www.gmc-uk.org/med_ed
D. Goleman (1995) Emotional Intelligence: Why is can Matter More than IQ Bantam New York
D. Goleman (1998) Working with Emotional Intelligence Bloomsbury London
D. Goleman (2001) An EI-based theory of performance C. Cherniss D. Goleman (Eds) The Emotionally Intelligent Workplace Jossey-Bass San Francisco 27–45
T. Graham W. Ickes (1997) When women’s intuition isn’t greater than men’s W. Ickes (Eds) Empathic Accuracy Guildford Press New York 117–143
R.M. Harden J.R. Crosby M.H. Davis M. Friedman (1999) ArticleTitleAMEE Guide No.14: Outcome-based education: Part 5-From competency to meta-competency: A model for the specification of learning outcomes Medical Teacher 21 547–552
J. Heron (1992) Feeling and Personhood Psychology in Another Key Sage London
P.J. Jordan N.M. Ashkanasy C.E.J. Hartel G.S. Hooper (2002) ArticleTitleWorkgroup emotional intelligence-Scale development and relationship to team process effectiveness and goal focus Human Resource Management Review 12 IssueID2 195–214 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1053-4822(02)00046-3
D.L. Kasman K. Fryer-Edwards C.H. Braddock (2003) ArticleTitleEducating for professionalism: Trainees’ emotional experiences on IM and paediatrics inpatient wards Academic Medicine 78 730–741
J. Lave E. Wenger (1991) Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation Cambridge University Press Cambridge
N. Lewis C. Rees N. Hudson (2004a) ArticleTitleHelping students identify their emotional intelligence Medical Education 38 563 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1365-2929.2004.01872.x
N. Lewis C.E. Rees J.N. Hudson (2004b) ArticleTitleExploring stakeholders’ views about what constitutes emotional intelligence in medical practitioners Educacion Medica Internacional Journal 7 134
D.S. Lind S. Rekkas V. Bui T. Lam E. Beierle E.M. Copeland (2002) ArticleTitleCompetency-based student self-assessment on a surgery rotation Journal of Surgical Research 105 31–34 Occurrence Handle10.1006/jsre.2002.6442
MacCulloch, T. (2001). Emotional competence: Teaching and assessment issues in health professional education. Presented at the ANZAME conference, July
F. Marton R. Saljo (1976) ArticleTitleOn qualitative differences in learning: outcome and process British Journal of Educational Psychology 46 4–11
G. Matthews M. Zeidner R.D. Roberts (2002) Emotional Intelligence: Science and Myth Massachusetts Institute of Technology Boston
J.D. Mayer P. Salovey (1997) What is emotional intelligence? P. Salovey D Sluyter (Eds) Emotional Development and Emotional Intelligence Basic Books New York 3–31
J.D. Mayer P. Salovey D.R. Caruso (2000) NoChapterTitle Test Manual for the Mayer, Salovey, Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test: Research Version 1.1 EditionNumber3 Multi-Health Systems Toronto, Canada
J.D. Mayer P. Salovey D.R. Caruso (2002) Mayer–Salovey–Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test (MSCEIT): User’s Manual Multi-Health Systems Toronto, Canada
D.C. McLelland (1998) ArticleTitleIdentifying competencies with behavioural-event interviews Psychological Science 9 331–340
R.R. McCrae (2000) Emotional Intelligence from the perspective of the five factor model of Personality R. Bar-on J.D.A. Parker J.D. Mayer (Eds) The Handbook of Emotional Intelligence Jossey-Bass San Francisco 263–276
B. McMullen (2003) ArticleTitleEmotional Intelligence Student British medical Journal 11 18–19
G.R. Norman (1999) ArticleTitleThe adult learner: A mythical species Academic Medicine 74 886–889
R.M. O’Conner I.S. Little (2003) ArticleTitleRevisiting the predictive validity of emotional intelligence: self-report versus ability-based measures Personality and Individual Differences 35 1893–1902
D. Paulhus D. Lysy M. Yik (1998) ArticleTitleSelf-report measures of intelligence: Are they useful as proxy IQ tests? Journal of Personality 66 523–555
K.V. Petrides A. Furnham (2000) ArticleTitleGender differences in measured and self-estimated trait emotional intelligence Sex Roles 42 449–461 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1007006523133
K.V. Petrides A. Furnham (2001) ArticleTitleTrait emotional intelligence: Psychometric investigation with reference to established trait taxonomies European Journal of Personality 15 425–448 Occurrence Handle10.1002/per.416
C. Rees (2003) ArticleTitleSelf-assessment scores and gender Medical Education 37 572 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1365-2923.2003.01545.x
C. Saarni (2000) Emotional competence a developmental perspective R. Bar-on J.D.A. Parker J.D. Mayer (Eds) The Handbook of Emotional Intelligence Jossey-Bass San Francisco 68–91
F. Sala (2002) Emotional Competence Inventory: Technical Manual McClelland Centre For Research, HayGroup. 2001 Philadelphia, PA
P. Salovey J.D. Mayer (1990) ArticleTitleEmotional intelligence Imagination, Cognition and Personality 9 185–211
N.S. Schutte J.M. Malouff L.E. Hall D.J. Haggerty J.T. Cooper C.J. Golden L. Dornheim (1998) ArticleTitleDevelopment and validation of a measure of emotional intelligence Personality and Individual Differences 25 167–177 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0191-8869(98)00001-4
L. Spencer (2001) The economic value of emotional intelligence competencies and EIC-based HR programmes C. Cherniss D. Goleman (Eds) The Emotionally Intelligent Workplace Jossey-Bass San Francisco 45–83
D.L. Rooy ParticleVan C. Viswesvaran (2004) ArticleTitleEmotional intelligence: A meta-analytic investigation of predictive validity and nomological net Journal of Vocational Behavior 65 71–95
L.S. Vygotsky (1978) Mind and Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes Harvard University Press Cambridge MA
P.J. Wagner D.M. Jester G.C. Moseley (2001) ArticleTitleUse of the Emotional Quotient Inventory in medical education Academic Medicine 76 506–507
L.A. Weinberger (2002) ArticleTitleEmotional intelligence: its connection to HRD theory and practice Human Resource Development 1 215–243
E. Wenger (1998) Communities of Practice: Learning Meaning and Identity Cambridge University Press Cambridge, MA
M. Zeidner G. Matthews R.D. Roberts (2001) ArticleTitleSlow down, you move too fast: emotional intelligence remains an ‘elusive’ intelligence Emotion 1 265–275 Occurrence Handle10.1037/1528-3542.1.3.265
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lewis, N.J., Rees, C.E., Hudson, J.N. et al. Emotional Intelligence Medical Education: Measuring the Unmeasurable?. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract 10, 339–355 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-005-4861-0
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-005-4861-0