Table 2

Summary of rationales for using arts-based health services research (ABHSR)

DomainSubdomain
Capture aspects of topic that may be overlooked, ignored or not conceptualised by other methodsEnables participants to convey their experiences with more contextual and historical depth
  • Provides more opportunities for individualised creative expression

  • Makes the reflections and emotional processing of participants more concrete

  • Explores topics from various angles

  • Conceptualises experiences from outside the norm of population

Identify or confirm problems in communities that may be amenable to collaboration and research
  • Informs communities about outcomes of an intervention, priority setting, raising awareness and tailoring interventions

  • Provides better access to data on the processes and mechanisms of behaviour change

  • Confers new future visions, strategies and policies

  • Creates novel analytical opportunities to learn about what matters to participants and why

Allows researchers to explore topics in marginalised and underserved groups
  • Creates environments that increase children participation in research

  • Increases the ability and capabilities of participants to community about their experiences compared with other methods

Prompts higher creativity with analysing participant experiences and perspectives
  • Provides powerful imagery for understanding experiences

  • Generates an opportunity to obtain an ‘insider view’

Enhance the recall and accuracy of participant narratives
  • Provides participants with physical prompts that may aid accurate recollection

Allows participants to better reflect on their own experiencesIndividual level
  • Allows individuals to engage in self-improvement

  • Encourages participants to engage in a ‘healing process’

  • Enables individuals to ‘find peace’ in previous traumatic experiences

  • Enriches self-understanding

Family level
  • Increases participant knowledge to motivate behaviour change and action

  • Improves communication within family about problems and difficulties

  • Encourages individuals to support family in reflection about community needs

Community level
  • Increases personal knowledge and empowerment that promotes engagement in broader community activities

Generate valuable community knowledge to inform intervention design and deliveryBuilds capacity for change
  • Provides tools to researchers to better understand communities and generate evidence that supports action and communication

Facilitates community discussion and critical reflection
  • Improves uptake and legitimacy of interventions

  • Use of methods that are more preferred by communities for research

  • Acknowledge that communities are experts in their own lives

Make research more participatoryBrings policy, advocacy and empowerment into research
  • Confers strong impact on policy and practice

  • Encourages behaviour change in broader community

  • Orients decision makers to attend to and act on findings

  • Increases the collaborative capacity of stakeholders, organisations and communities

  • Builds and sustains partnerships between stakeholders

  • Allows for improved collaboration between participants

Encourages participants to adopt a more active role in research
  • Minimises attrition

  • Encourages participants to become leaders in their community

  • Adds a more person-centred approach to research

  • Stimulates dialogue on hidden issues

  • Transforms relationships between participants and researchers

  • Shifts power from researchers to participants

  • Teaching and learning occur from participants to researchers

  • Avoids passive forms of representation and engagement

  • Promotes choice and agency in the research process