43 e-Letters

  • Composing causes of death and disease
    David van Bodegom

    Caruncho and Fernandez interpreted Chopin's hallucinations as temporal lobe epilepsy.(1) Recently, Karhausen examined the 140 causes of death of Mozart that have been proposed in the medical literature.(2) These studies on both composers nicely illustrate how a mechanistic view of death and disease still dominates modern medicine.

    Identifying the cause of death can be difficult. Many physicians will share the e...

    Show More
  • Reflection depends on culture as much as on language
    Deen M Mirza

    Dear Editor

    I read this article with great interest, as it relates closely to my own practice teaching final year students in the Middle East. An important outcome of our family medicine clerkship in the UAE is the ability to reflect - upon oneself, one's patients and the healthcare system within which the students work.

    Many students find this type of analysis difficult. Part of this may be related to...

    Show More
  • Alternative Medicine is a Useful Concept
    Harri Hemila
    Pekka Louhiala argues that "there is no alternative medicine" because "it escapes a meaningful definition, and 'alternative medicine' cannot be clearly differentiated from conventional medicine" [1]. I do not consider that his arguments are valid.

    Louhiala does not mention the proposed definitions for "alternative medicine". For example, Eisenberg defined alternative medical therapies as "interventions neither taught...
    Show More
  • Response
    S J Lund

    I believe no mental patient should have family members make decisions for them, as this can make the patient even more irritable. Ask the patient what they want to achieve. Just like when someone is dying you wouldn't disrespect their wishes.

    Conflict of Interest:

    None declared

  • another reference in Jules Romains
    Jillian I Fryer

    You might also be interested in the character of Doctor Bompard (is this name a French pun?) in Jules Romains' The Body's Rapture and his long speech towards the end of the book, pages 428-429. This is not specifically about medicine, though Bompard is a ship's doctor, but about the purported march forward of science and philosophy since the Renaisance and of course refering back to the ancient Greeks. In this case it i...

    Show More
  • Can surrogates provide consent?
    Partha Gangopadhyay

    The article “Medical paternalism in House M.D”. by M R Wicclair in Medical Humanities 2008;34:93-99 made for interesting reading. However there is one point which needs further clarification in the context of English Law. The author states “Informed consent—the principle that, except in emergency situations, medical interventions require the voluntary and informed consent of patients or their surrogates—is a core ethical...

    Show More
  • Wounded Healers
    Jacqueline L. Mosher

    Dear Editor: In the editorial written by Deborah Kirklin, "Lessons in Pity and Caring from Dickens to Melville" (Medical Humanities 34: 57 2008)I found it interesting and refreshing to read her perspective on the character Gregory House from the popular television series "House M.D." I have noticed many articles referencing paternalism and the popular television series "House," but Kirklin makes an interesting point th...

    Show More
  • Is beauty only skin deep?
    Kenneth Hoekstra

    Dear Editor,

    In the article by Volandes titled Envying Cinderella and the future of medical enhancements (1), Medical Humanities 32: 73-76, 2006, the author highlights the ethical dilemma of providing medical enhancements for patients while corroding the moral priority that it has traditionally held as a profession, namely retaining a position of trust based on professional judgment and advocating for patient's...

    Show More
  • Doctors as Nietzschean supermen?
    Colin Parker

    This response to T J Papadimos outlines some of the relevant elements in Nietzsche’s philosophy in order to develop its conclusions. We find that Papadimos’s attempt to illuminate the causes of litigation against doctors in America fails through misunderstanding the analysis of convention and the idea of the superman in Nietzsche’s thought.

    Papadimos’s perspective [1] is rather odd, he points out that ‘Medical...

    Show More
  • Indoctrination in the NHS
    Ruth V Reed

    As a student, I prided myself on having an independent and often controversial approach to a whole host of contemporary issues. I confess I looked down on those junior doctors a few years ahead of me who seemed to do nothing except work and bland activities such as ‘going to the gym’. Where was their activism, their passion? Surely I would be different, campaigning for change on issues that mattered most – the developing...

    Show More