Regular Article
Practising photography: an archive, a study, some photographs and a researcher

https://doi.org/10.1006/jhge.2000.0247Get rights and content

Abstract

This paper begins from the assumption that the meanings of a photograph are established through its uses. This point has been well made by a number of historical geographers in recent arguments for the importance of photography as a record of historically-specific ways of seeing the world. This paper, however, extends that argument, and focuses on the relationships between the photograph and the historical geographer. Drawing on my own experiences of working in the Print Room of the Victoria and Albert Museum looking at photographs taken by Lady Hawarden in the mid-nineteenth century, I discuss the effects of that archive both on them and on myself as a researcher. I argue that that archive is a powerful space which to a certain degree allies the visual and spatial resources of the photographs and the research practice of the historical geographer to its own discipline; but I also argue that its discipline can be disrupted by its own contradictory discourses and by other relationships between researcher and the photographs. In conclusion, I ask for more consideration to be given to contemporary research practice in relation to historical photographs. Historical geographers cannot themselves claim to be merely the descriptive recorders of history and geography if they wish to deny this status to photographs.

References (47)

  • R. Barthes

    Camera Lucida

    (London 1982)
  • Idem,...
  • D. Matless, Visual culture and geographical citizenship: England in the 1940s, Journal of Historical Geography, 22,...
  • S. Lalvani, Photography, Vision and the Production of Modern Bodies, Albany 1996, M. Rosler, In, around, and...
  • Schwartz, The Geography Lesson, 29,...
  • Schwartz, The Geography Lesson,...
  • Schwartz, The Geography Lesson,...
  • M. Crang

    Picturing practices: research through the tourist gaze

    Progress in Human Geography

    (1997)
  • Schwartz, The Geography Lesson, 35, my...
  • G. Rose

    Situating knowledges: positionality, reflexivities and other tactics

    Progress in Human Geography

    (1997)
  • Several feminist historians have noted that processes closely connected to the unconscious, such as seduction, desire...
  • Barthes, op. cit.,...
  • M. Bal

    Reading «Rembrandt»: Beyond the Word-Image Opposition

    (Cambridge 1991)
  • For essays making this point, see, C. Armstrong, Cupid's pencil of light: Julia Margaret Cameron and the...
  • A. Sekula

    Reading an archive: photography between labour and capital, in P. Holland., J. Spence and S. Watney (Eds)

    Photography/Politics Two

    (London 1986)
  • Sekula, Reading an archive, 154, Sekula here is relying on what is an over-simple distinction between a more authentic,...
  • Sekula, Reading an archive,...
  • B. Brothman

    Orders of value: probing the theoretical terms of archive practice

    Archivaria

    (1991)
  • C. Pinney, The parallel histories of anthropology and photography, in E. Edwards (Ed.), Anthropology and Photography...
  • Tagg, The Burden of Representation,...
  • Sekula, Reading an archive,...
  • Hawarden Collection Catalogue Raisonnée (hereafter Catalogue), Vol. 1,...
  • Catalogue, Vol. 1,...
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text