rss
Med Humanities 34:53
  • Book review
    • PostScript

Fourteen stories: doctors, patients, and other strangers

Jay Baruch. Published by The Kent State University Press Kent, Ohio 2007 pp 152, $18.95 (paperback). ISBN 0-87338-894-8
  1. R Knight
  1. R Knight, Department of Medical and Social Care Education, University of Leicester, Maurice Shock Medical Sciences Building, PO Box 138, Leicester, LE1 9HW, UK; rk89{at}le.ac.uk

    “There are only three events that happen once and only once during a lifetime … birth, death, and loss of virginity. You control one of these moments. Give him a good death.” Photo Eddie, a tirelessly committed clinician, is talking to Sophie, a third-year medical student, about a young man with end-stage AIDS in one of Jay Baruch’s Fourteen stories … By the time the reader has reached this 11th story, entitled “Dissections”, however, he would be forgiven for thinking that even in death there is no control. A good death, if it exists, is not often seen.

    The 14 fictional stories in this anthology are each written around central, well-developed characters. The afterword, “Narrative’s disaster zone”, is a composite of memory from the writer’s long experience of emergency medicine. All of the stories but one relate in some way to death. Each draws the reader into a dark world typified by nihilism and futility. There is very little joy. The emotional impact is great—the hopelessness and emptiness of the writing dragging the reader, very subtly, into a pit …